DNR Status and Hospital Mortality Measures Postmyocardial Infarction: Differentiating Preventable From Unpreventable Deaths in CMS Data.
Publicly reported 30-day acute myocardial infarction (AMI) mortality rates are widely used to benchmark hospital performance. However, these measures may lack validity when they include deaths among patients with do-not-resuscitate (DNR) orders or those receiving palliative care-groups for whom mortality may be expected and goal-concordant.
We analyzed the national 100% Medicare Inpatient Standard Analytic File and Medicare Beneficiary Summary file to assess 30-day AMI mortality rates stratified by DNR status (absent, present-on-admission, and postadmission) and palliative care involvement. We then conducted a retrospective chart review of all 30-day AMI mortalities at a single academic medical center (2019-2025), applying Global Registry of Acute Coronary Events and a Palliative Performance Scale scores to identify unpreventable deaths, which we defined as a Global Registry of Acute Coronary Events >190.5 or Palliative Performance Scale ≤40%. Global Registry of Acute Coronary Events is a risk-stratification tool using clinical and laboratory variables whereas the Palliative Performance Scale is a bedside functional status and palliative care assessment quantifying patient's self-care ability.
Across n=467 259 total AMI encounters, mean (SD) age was 75.1 (10.5), and the population was 44% female. Thirty-day mortality was 10.4% (39 112/376 062) among patients without DNRs, 43.1% (26 181/60 719) in those with present-on-admission DNR, and 72.1% (21 984/30 478) in those with postadmission DNR. Among 9.2% (43 090/467 259) of encounters with palliative care, there was a 76.9% mortality rate (33 151/43 090). Hazard ratios for mortality were 5.25 (95% CI, 5.17-5.33) for present-on-admission DNR and 10.73 (95% CI, 10.55-10.91) for postadmission DNR as compared with encounters without DNRs. Among n=24 AMI mortalities at our institution, 71% (17/24) had DNRs, and 33% (8/24) met the unpreventable death criteria.
The validity of 30-day AMI mortality metrics may be undermined by their inclusion of high-acuity, end-of-life patients, which may disincentivize hospitals from delivering appropriate, patient-centered care. Removal of DNR or palliative cases from performance measures should be explored to better identify opportunities for reducing preventable deaths.
We analyzed the national 100% Medicare Inpatient Standard Analytic File and Medicare Beneficiary Summary file to assess 30-day AMI mortality rates stratified by DNR status (absent, present-on-admission, and postadmission) and palliative care involvement. We then conducted a retrospective chart review of all 30-day AMI mortalities at a single academic medical center (2019-2025), applying Global Registry of Acute Coronary Events and a Palliative Performance Scale scores to identify unpreventable deaths, which we defined as a Global Registry of Acute Coronary Events >190.5 or Palliative Performance Scale ≤40%. Global Registry of Acute Coronary Events is a risk-stratification tool using clinical and laboratory variables whereas the Palliative Performance Scale is a bedside functional status and palliative care assessment quantifying patient's self-care ability.
Across n=467 259 total AMI encounters, mean (SD) age was 75.1 (10.5), and the population was 44% female. Thirty-day mortality was 10.4% (39 112/376 062) among patients without DNRs, 43.1% (26 181/60 719) in those with present-on-admission DNR, and 72.1% (21 984/30 478) in those with postadmission DNR. Among 9.2% (43 090/467 259) of encounters with palliative care, there was a 76.9% mortality rate (33 151/43 090). Hazard ratios for mortality were 5.25 (95% CI, 5.17-5.33) for present-on-admission DNR and 10.73 (95% CI, 10.55-10.91) for postadmission DNR as compared with encounters without DNRs. Among n=24 AMI mortalities at our institution, 71% (17/24) had DNRs, and 33% (8/24) met the unpreventable death criteria.
The validity of 30-day AMI mortality metrics may be undermined by their inclusion of high-acuity, end-of-life patients, which may disincentivize hospitals from delivering appropriate, patient-centered care. Removal of DNR or palliative cases from performance measures should be explored to better identify opportunities for reducing preventable deaths.
Authors
Pollock Pollock, Danks Danks, Chirila Chirila, Moreno Franco Moreno Franco, Ray Ray, Dowdy Dowdy, Cowart Cowart
View on Pubmed